Saturday, May 31, 2008

What are you doing with your gov't rebate check?

Now that the rebate checks are in the mail and the economic stimulus package is well under way, what are the consumers doing? Clearly the government is hoping you will spend, spend, spend. Unfortunately for retailers, the needle barely moved on consumer spending which was up only 0.2% in April. I had expected more companies to actively market to $106.7 billion up for grabs after Congress passed the bill in February. So far the only thing noticeable is the lack of spending by the consumer and the lack of marketing by the advertisers.

Perhaps overcoming four straight months of job losses, a wobbly stock market, plunging home prices and record high gasoline price hasn't left consumers in a buying mood no matter where the money is coming. But that would be responsible buying behavior and that's NOT the American consumer I know.

Friday, May 30, 2008

New Targets

With mobile phones being the new big thing in advertising I thought it would be interesting to examine another sector in the mobile market, that of the phones themselves and how they are targeted. Specifically I've been reading a little about the next generation of smartphones and found it interesting to see how trends have been going recently.

Since their inception smartphones have been designed and targeted towards mobile professionals, or people with lots of money and the need for nifty gadgets. But business has really been the target because the features designed into such devices naturally lend themselves to business. You'd only see Blackberries on those that got them from work to keep in touch via email at all times.

But then in the last few years there has been a shift in the marketing of these products. Now Blackberries are being loaded up with features and apps that are meant to appeal to a wider consumer base and not being targeted solely towards businesses anymore. They are trying to become the phone for anyone and everyone who talks, texts and emails.

The flip side is the iPhone, created for the individual, they are now working to incorporate enterprise email capabilities to begin to market towards businesses. While I personally haven't seen much marketing on either of these products yet, except for the writeups online that I've read, I think it will be very interesting to see how things pan out when the next generation of Blackberry and iPhone hit the shelves and start really competing for similar targets.

Thursday, May 29, 2008

Differentiation: The Wii Factor

“We are not competing against Sony or Microsoft. We are battling the indifference of people who have no interest in videogames” – Satoru Iwata, President and CEO, Nintendo Co.

As Microsoft and Sony spent heavily to beef up their next gen systems, Wii has quietly taken a relatively low tech machine and proudly winning the console match. Wii is practically sold out everywhere these days, 16 months after its Dec ’06 launch - an amazing feat in this highly competitive industry.

Here’s a quick comparison for the 3 machines.

Differentiation is exactly how Wii has won it.

Video games and systems are getting more complicated. Think of Wii as the McDonalds answer to Starbucks. By offering less capabilities from its counterparts, Wii focused on being simple, innovative (Wii Remote) and fun. A differentiation strategy is effectively only when it’s valued by the customers. Xbox360 and PS3 are leaps and bounds ahead (technology) of Wii, but by focusing on game expansion, Nintendo is bringing the “fun” factors back to gaming.

Pricing at loss for market penetration

I was surprised to know that when Microsoft first launched xbox, they were losing around $100 on each xbox sold. They had to match PS2 pricing even though they had features like network card, hard drive. But the idea was to make up for that loss on sales of the games. I think it worked great but can only be tried by companies with huge cash reserves.

Wednesday, May 28, 2008

Can you find what's offensive?

Sometimes I really think our country is in this mode of being too hypersensitive about any potential perceived offensiveness in any advertisement. How far are we supposed to go as marketers to ensure that nobody could ever be offended by something in an advertisement? How much resources do you have to spend towards ensuring everything is 'clean'? I'm all for doing a minimum amount of research into other cultures, languages, etc. to see how your message could be interpreted. However, in general I think the hypersensitivity of things that could potentially be offensive is getting a little out of control in recent years.

Could you spot what's offensive by just looking at the picture alone (given you haven't already heard about this story yet)?

Rebates - its one fact of pricing strategy

During class this evening there was lot of discussion on rebates. Whether we like them or not they are part of the pricing strategy manufactures use to "push" their products. I came across an article that you may find useful (sorry it is lengthy) - http://www.cba.ufl.edu/mkt/docs/janiszewski/Rebate.pdf

As a Marketing Manager I have successfully used rebates in the past to promote a product, and yes sales during the period the rebate was offered did increase by 12%. One may argue if the increase in sales was directly related to rebate or other factors? Yes, most of the incremental increase was directly attributed to the rebate.

Happy reading

Is Customer Service Part of Marketing

If is not it certainly should be!

These companies I would guess do not have and empowered CMO's. One would also surmise that the CMO is shouldering at least some of the responsibility. As you read the article click on the link for the best 25 companies at customer service. You will notice that good and the bad can come from like industries.

All the revenue comes from our customers and I once read that a bad service experience gets told to 11 people on average while good service get passed on only once.

Should the org-chart have customer service under marketing? I would like to read others thoughts on this subject.

Marketing and Sales

How much does marketing really matter?

Maybe that's a terrible way to begin a blog for a marketing class, but I find myself struggling at my small company with making marketing relevant to the sales process. Even when marketing conducts research and analysis that resultsin very specific, targeted plans, the sales force may veer off in an entirely different direction. Obviously that's partly a management issue, but it's also a challenge that I think marketers should be willing to take up to further the strategic advantage of the company as a whole.

It's also a challenge for our MBA program. By definition we have few (or no) people who are in a purely sales role participating in the program because of the travel requirements of their jobs. To better integrate the roles of sales and marketing in my company I think that my marketing programs need to be more tactical and less strategic. Strategy still plays a role, but a gut feeling for effective strategies develops with time, experience, and observation of what sales processes do and don't work.

Over the course of a year and a half I think that I've been able to educate my management chain (VP of Sales) about the role of marketing, how it supports sales, and how it must be fundamentally have a more long-term focus than quarterly sales numbers. How do other people reconcile the conflicting agendas of marketing and sales at their companies?

Advertising Kudos to Microsoft

Some entertaining ads fail to ingrain the product or brand into memory. I think MS succeeded at both missions with this ad for their entertainment title, Flight Simulator.

Have Film For Free...or Kinda

NPR reported that former Disney main-guy, Michael Eisner, is producing 2 minute videos to download for free. At least the first 50 in the series. If you want the rest of the story there is a price.

Videos for sale is nothing new, but the model he is following is the same one Doug and I got to explore with music downloads: selling direct to the customer via download. Customer gets to try it and see if they like it. If so, order on. If not, no investment from consumer's pocket is lost.

I am left with the impression that there are dollar signs in Eisner's eyes - he sees this as a huge opportunity to get big money, big talent, big distribution - reach and in cost savings, big production cost savings.

Releases soon - interesting to see how it goes.

You can listen to an installment here.

I'll Take the Purple Pill, Please

I happened to be in that psuedo-invisible position at my doctor's office: that time when she stands in the doorway talking admin stuff with staff before turning her attentions to me. She said something that really caught my attention. With visible exasperation she said, "If I hear one more color-pill request I'll scream."

I decided to ask what she was talking about. She explained that a patient had just requested 'those yellow pills'. She said that since the drug companies have been marketing to the patient - they used to market to the doctors - she gets color-coded pill requests every week. She attributes it to a pain killer in the 80s advertised as 'Little, Yellow, Different' and 'The Purple Pill' ads. The ads worked, but she says now she hears about green, purple, yellow, red and orange pills that the patient wants her to prescribe. Problem is that they get the colors confused.

I had never thought about the confusion that might occur as patients try to convey what they want using the 'ad lingo' rather than specific drug names.

Next step is the polka-dot pill - stay away from colors all together.

Tuesday, May 27, 2008

Let's Refuel a Brand: Chrysler's $2.99 Gas Guarantee

I'm sure you've all seen a commmercial or two lately that mentioned Chrysler's new marketing campaign: "Let's Refuel America". Buy any new vehicle and Chrysler will give you a gas card linked to your Visa keeping gas at $2.99 a gallon for three years. My first thought, after filling up at $4 a gallon, was that Chrysler was willing to eat a lot of money to make sales volumes.

On closer examination, this is really a very clever incentive program. Whereas automakers typically give up the farm by offering hefty cash rebates or 0% financing to sell cars, Chrysler is betting gas will stay at a reasonable range (below $5) for three years and actually keeping more profit than it would with financing and rebate programs.

And they're targeting an area where they currently perform quite poorly. Gas prices are everywhere in the news, everybody is unhappy about the cost to fill up their cars, and Chrysler only offers gas guzzlers that no one wants. Even with traditional incentives, the first thing most consumers will be looking at in May is gas mileage. Since it will take a couple of years to get some new vehicles down the pipeline, Chrysler can direct attention away from the gas mileage of its current lineup and say, "but you'll only be paying $2.99 a gallon."

I just think it's a great experiment to take what consumers percieve as one of your greatest weaknesses, poor mileage, and morph it into a strength. They've managed to associate themselves with an issue that's recieving huge nationwide attention. By "doing something" about high gas prices, they may have rapidly entered consideration sets they never would have been in. And if consumers go for it, they'll make more money than on traditional incentives. Here are some early results.

Game marketing


Until recently game marketing resonated with only the in-game ads in my mind. But when I started to understand digital marketing better, I was fascinated by the kind of options that the game marketers have in recent years. I think it all started with a change in perception that gamers are not just typical teen/young male anymore but
it does include both genders and varying age group. Refer the picture embedded in this article (source: "Why game marketing matters?" article from Forrester research) to know about Game marketer's choices.
Clearly there are more options, increased marketing budgets and an increased adoption to try out new emerging techniques in marketing. Check out http://www.postopia.com for instance. This is a gaming website targeted to promote all products sold by Kraft. ALso, surveys indicate that lesser consumers are annoyed (35%) by gaming ads compared to online ads( 85% annoyed). Also they have indicated they might consider the advertised while shopping.

I know we have some ardent gamers in our class. What are thoughts on how this type of marketing will shape up. Do you get annoyed with in-game ads?

Mobile Marketing

I recently read this article talking about how some companies are targeting iPhone users with 'right-sized' websites and advertisements that better fit its 3.5" screen. Next month, Apple will be releasing a software development kit for the iPhone, enabling external developers to create custom software and potentially shape advertisements through 'geo-targeting,' based on user's GPS coordinates. Should marketer's be required to get user consent before placing geo-targeted ads?

Monday, May 26, 2008

Marketing your stock

Not the best way to market your stock:

Two years ago we were selling at 10 times revenues when we were at $64. At 10 times revenues, to give you a 10-year payback, I have to pay you 100% of revenues for 10 straight years in dividends. That assumes I can get that by my shareholders. That assumes I have zero cost of goods sold, which is very hard for a computer company. That assumes zero expenses, which is really hard with 39,000 employees. That assumes I pay no taxes, which is very hard. And that assumes you pay no taxes on your dividends, which is kind of illegal. And that assumes that with zero R&D for the next 10 years, I can maintain the current revenue run rate. Now, having done that, would any of you like to buy my stock at $64? Do you realize how ridiculous those basic assumptions are? You don't need any transparency. You don't need any footnotes. What were you thinking?
Scott McNealy, CEO of Sun Microsystems, Business Week, April 2002.

Microsoft's Cashback Program: Marketing Genius or Gimmick?

Last Wednesday, Microsoft unveiled its Live Search Cashback program, it's latest attempt to increase Live Search's market share. Consumers can shop for products using this feature, and then compare prices from all featured retailers. Whatever discounts are offered will go directly from the retailer into a cashback account that the consumer can redeem. Here's another description of the program.
While this is a clever way to increase brand awareness for the search engine, it also may prove to be a more efficient marketing tool for retailers. Rather than paying per click, retailers will only pay per action, when consumers actually buy something. This could be a marketing win-win situation for both Microsoft's search engine and its featured retailers.
But will consumers enjoy this feature, or will it be too complex? The cashback can't be redeemed until 60 days after the purchase, and it depends on the retailers offering their best price. For example, I found my Canon SD750 digital camera for $199, or $189 after cashback from Circuit City using the Live Search program. But I could have gotten it for $179 direct from Circuit City's website. How does this make my shopping experience easier?

The Power of Marketing

The ‘standard’ Economic model posits that price is defined by the intersection of supply and demand. In statistics, consumer spending was shown to have increased such that consumer spending is now greater then consumer income. Therefore, because buying power hasn’t decreased and rewards for saving are mostly constant, it appears consumer demand has increased. Are there ‘better’ things to spend money on or has the US cultural perspective changed?

Specifically, what are the effects of marketing on US culture and on savings trends? What is the impact on the economy and national productivity? Considering the number of hours/week that the average US youth spends in front of the television and surfing the internet how will marketing effect their future purchasing/savings decisions?

Thanks,
Eric

Friday, May 23, 2008

Nordstrom's in the news

According to the times, Nordstroms is about to start an online buying service, but you'll pick up your items in the store. That's a pretty interesting idea. One may suppose the point is to avoid losing the opportunity to deliver the famous Nordstrom "service", which is quite legitimately part of their brand. Once Nordy's stuff is delivered by mail, its not easy to maintain that brand over any other internet store. However, why bother at all? Clearly, Nordies doesn't want to lose a sale to someone who shops on-line.

I look forward to how this pans out. I don't know anyone who shops on-line for convenience, and likes the idea of having to provide their own transport for the goods after the sale. The mail is simply the most convenient method for me to receive my goods. I would think the shopping experience itself is an important time for enjoying Norstrom's branded service.




http://seattletimes.nwsource.com/html/businesstechnology/2004427084_nordstrom21.html

Bob B

Cell Phone Ads...Influence in the Pocket?

During the class presentation on marketing through cell phone ads (e.g. alerts of nearby fast food restaurants) the point was raised that some consumers view this form of advertising as intrusive.

An issue that has been on my mind with this and for that matter all types of marketing is the degree to which certain, specific, strategies may annoy the customer.

Question:
If you had to wait 10 seconds for a Burger King ad (on your cell phone) when trying to make a call on your cell phone, would you be annoyed? (Maybe a lower cell phone bill might help to render this)?

Anyway, the effects on our view of burger king are at least 2-fold:
1. Burger King is on our mind (good for Burger King)
2. Burger King and feeling annoyed coincide (‘Pavlovian bad’ for Burger King).

Is effect 2 relevant? Should marketers consider this? Is it ok for Burger King but more of a problem for higher-end establishments? (i.e. Is this uniquely appropriate given the addictive nature of french-fries and a Whopper (for some customers))? Could this type of advertising push some consumers over the edge (‘I can’t quit BK!’)?

Thanks,
Eric

Thursday, May 22, 2008

Chief brand officer

Off late, I run into companies announcing their new CBOs. Wasn't this always part of a chief marketing officer's role who along with driving all marketing initiatives also took care of promoting the brand? I'm starting to wonder whether its a byproduct of title inflations ( chief xyz officers like diversity officer, cultural officer etc) or a genuinely required title to have more focus on promoting a company brand?
Does your company have a CBO? If yes, do you also have marketing officers? continuing on our discussions from yesterday's class, do you see them hands on at the trade shows evangelizing the brand and listening to customers?

Open Source as a form of branding?

It occurred to me that Open Source software is a form of branding. People tend to have certain associations with the label "open source" similar to the associations that are carried with a brand.

In the case of open source software, these associations might be positive or negative, things like "free", "flexible", "hard to use", "unsupported", "community supported", "dynamic and growing", "unstable", "secure", etc. These associations are contrasted with associations that people might have about commercial software, like "supported", "easy to install/use", "greedy", "unresponsive", etc. Commercial software companies recognize this, and try to strengthen the perception of their brand vs. the open-source "brand".

What do you all think of this?

I did a bit of research, and came across something entirely different:

http://www.trendwatching.com/about/inmedia/articles/insperiences/open_source_branding_invite_cu.html

Apparently some people are promoting open-source brands, in which consumers help define the brand image itself. Interesting stuff.

Wednesday, May 21, 2008

Kobe and Aston Martin Ad - Part 2

This is a spoof and parody to the Kobe/Aston Martin ad.



The original ad was a huge hit. Even the Air Jordans don’t come close.

This is one of the finest examples of viral marketing at its best – low cost (this has to be the lowest cost for a Nike ad EVER), buzz worthy, entertaining and SUPER effective. Since the ad went live in late March, it generated more than 20 million views on YouTube alone. Just the sheer number of spoofs and parodies alone have valided the success. Simply WOW....

Using YouTube as the distribution channel, it opens up a world of opportunities for viral marketing.

Here’s another spoof while we are at it.

Why don't I buy store brands

We were discussing branding the other day and one of the things that hit me is the fact that I never buy store brands. The natural question I get to is "why?". The answer, I have absolutely no idea. On Sunday, while in Safeway I see two cans of corn, a store brand and a national brand. I immediately grabbed the national brand, but having thought about this some this week I bought the store brand which was cheaper. Turns out the store brand tastes exactly the same. Problem is, even with this knowledge I really don't intend to buy it again.

I stumbled across an article I thought I'd share on why store brands don't do quite so well. It seems I suffer from Issue #1 in the article. As it turns out I'm not the only one who discriminates against store brands. With my new found awareness I suppose I should work on overcoming that prejudice and seek out the objective truth. http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m0YQW/is_2000_Sept/ai_65227364/pg_1

Subliminal marketing

I was talking to my co-worker who happened to notice a subliminal message in a recent KFC ad. A $1 bill was nicely camouflaged in the KFC snacker. Sure enough I checked on Youtube and I found this : http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MunPARnI0dE

It makes me wonder whether such subliminal ads are really effective?

I looked up for some more information on companies who do such subliminal ads and KFC seems to be the one who had consistently done that.

"KFC is stepping it up a notch and actually providing an incentive for people to seek out the ad, offering a free sandwich to those who can regurgitate the hidden phrase. Imagine that: there may soon be a day when we record shows not because we enjoy them, but because advertisers have told us that they'll give us free swag if we comply." source :
http://www.engadget.com/2006/02/23/kfc-leverages-dvr-time-shifting-to-its-advantage/

Many marketers explicitly deny placing subliminal ads and television networks reject such ads when they promptly notice them. For example, ABC network had stopped airing ads that they considered had subliminal messaging.

These ads create enough stir ( especially when mixed with sex ingredient ) that its been followed by avid readers and may be the marketers have succeeded getting attention. But on the other hand, why would you want to bury a hidden message and have the networks ban your ads?

I'm curious to know what your thoughts are on this type of marketing practice.

SNL takeoff on NBA playoff ad.